Wander With Wonder – Discovering Wow Moments Around the World or Across the Street
Discover five of the world’s most exclusive islands, where limited access, secluded stays, and seasonal experiences make November through March an exceptional time to visit.
Some of the most exclusive islands in the world feel exclusive because of what a room costs. The islands in this guide, though, are exclusive in a more literal sense: a visitor cap, limited accommodations, or a guest-only policy keeps numbers small enough that the destination can truly feel like your own.
Each one also has a moment between November and March that makes a trip worth timing, so think of this as a calendar as much as a wish list.
Let’s dive into the most exclusive islands you should visit.
Shallow coral reefs fringe beautiful islands. Photo by Velvetfish via iStock by Getty Images
Fogo Island, Canada, for a Wild Late Fall
Fogo Island Inn stands on stilts above the granite shoreline of Fogo Island, off Canada’s northeast coast, with just 29 rooms and suites facing the North Atlantic. The island marks seven seasons rather than four, and November belongs to Late Fall, when gales roll in, and the ocean puts on a show beyond the inn’s tall windows. Moose and saltwater lamb come onto the menu, and stays include most land-based outings led by the inn’s Community Hosts, local residents who share the island’s trails and outport traditions.
Most visitors land at Gander International Airport, then spend about two hours on the road and the ferry. Guests who travel with private jet arrangements can land at Gander and continue by small plane or helicopter to the island’s airstrip in about half an hour, turning a long travel day into a relaxed afternoon.
Lord Howe Island, Australia, for a Capped Southern Summer
Lord Howe Island sits in the Tasman Sea off New South Wales, and only 400 tourists are allowed on it at any one time. Visitors need confirmed accommodation before booking a flight, and with roughly as many residents as guests, locals describe the result as a one-for-one visitor-to-local experience. The cap protects a landscape on UNESCO’s World Heritage List since 1982, from the lagoon and its coral reef to the twin peaks of Mount Gower and Mount Lidgbird.
The airport’s short runway takes small turboprops rather than jets, so most visitors connect through Sydney, around two hours away by air. Private aircraft can land with prior approval from the Lord Howe Island Board, which also runs strict biosecurity checks to protect the island’s native wildlife. December through February brings the southern summer, the season for snorkeling the lagoon and hiking above it.
Mountains and lagoon on Lord Howe Island. Photo by cuthbert48 courtesy of iStock via Getty Images
North Island, Seychelles, for Turtle Season
North Island lies about 20 miles northwest of Mahé, and the whole island is given over to just 11 villas, each with its own pool. Guests arrive by a 20-minute helicopter transfer from Mahé’s international airport, making the final leg after a long-haul flight feel like part of the stay. Stays are fully inclusive, and each villa comes with bicycles for getting around the island.
Between October and March, hawksbill turtles come ashore across the Seychelles to nest, and unusually they do it in daylight. Hawksbill and green turtles both nest on North Island, where an environmental team monitors the beaches as part of a long-running project to restore native habitat and bring back endangered species.
Mustique for the Blues at Basil’s
Mustique is run by the Mustique Company, which its homeowners own, and stays are limited to guests of its villas and The Cotton House hotel. The island’s modern story began when Colin Tennant bought it in 1958 and later gave Princess Margaret a plot as a wedding gift. The company formed in 1968, and its role as custodian of the whole 1,400-acre island keeps Mustique so private.
No jet can land on Mustique’s short airstrip. Visitors fly into Barbados, St. Lucia or Martinique and connect on an 18-seat Twin Otter shuttle, a 25-minute hop from St. Lucia or about 50 minutes from Barbados. Planes cannot land after sunset, so international arrivals need to touch down by 3:30 p.m. The reward comes in late January and early February, when the Mustique Blues Festival takes over Basil’s Bar on Britannia Bay, a tradition since 1995 whose proceeds support local education.
Photo by SketchbookDesign via iStock by Getty Images
St. Barts for Superyacht Season
St. Barts limits arrivals in its own way. Its airport is named for Rémy de Haenen, the aviation pioneer who made the first landing on the island. The strip is only about 650 meters (just over 2,100 feet) and accommodates small aircraft with roughly 19 seats, so there are no direct long-haul flights. Larger planes land on St. Maarten, and the connection from there takes about ten minutes.
Every March, the St Barths Bucket returns to Gustavia. The regatta has gathered sailing superyachts every March since 1995, and after each day’s racing the quay fills with dockside crew parties. In recent years, the fleet has numbered 40 or more yachts, yet the event has kept the relaxed, non-commercial spirit it started with.
When to Visit the World’s Most Exclusive Islands
The most exclusive islands in the world prove that true luxury can be as much about limited access and uncrowded experiences as lavish accommodations. Whether you time your visit for turtle nesting in the Seychelles, summer on Lord Howe Island, or superyacht season in St. Barts, planning ahead is essential when availability is limited by design. Explore more extraordinary destinations, luxury escapes, and expert travel tips on Wander With Wonder as you plan your next journey.
.
The post 5 of the World’s Most Exclusive Islands Worth Visiting appeared first on Wander With Wonder.